This week, just yesterday as a matter
of fact, our Prime Minister landed in Israel
- the first ever Prime Ministerial visit to that nation from our side.
This is a seminal event; yet, it was saddening to see some voices being
guarded, as opposed to openly welcoming this move. In a democracy, it is
perfectly fine if you don’t support the ruling party, having voted for the
other side; it is accepted as well as expected that you criticize – but when
the Government does something laudable – you should welcome it.
This move by the NaMo Government
stands in that list; a fully laudable move, one that we would do well to
welcome, leaving our apprehensions aside for the time being. On that other hand
– this is not a time for chest-thumping either; let us reflect what this move
means for us as a nation, and analyse the pluses and the minuses of this new
equation. Whatever else we look at, this
is not the time for misguided moralistic analyses – Geopolitics is not a field
that lends itself to excessive moralization, to be honest. You have to be
extremely hard-nosed and practical in Geopolitics.
THE
MORAL OBJECTIONS
These stem from the Israel-Palestine
issue; and the hard-nosed Israeli response. I feel for the problem, to be
honest; but I have to admit with deep
regret that they aren’t Indians – and Indian interests have to be placed first.
I don’t say I like the way it is being handled – but there is little we can
do, beyond a point. We aren’t the world police – and neither do we want to be
the world policeman either. The only
way to look at this problem is from a Geopolitical angle; not a right-and-wrong
angle.
Further, it is surprising to note
objections being raised basis Palestine, and in some cases China: I do not
recall many voices questioning our relationship with the USA, which actively
sends arms and aid to Pakistan, and which was the original provider of weapons
to our enemy, leading from the Afghan conflict. The continuing support from the
USA to Pakistan is a matter of documented record – and yet few people raised a question as
we went closer to the USA. Where were these moralizing objections then?
Not only that, Is the USA’s record
crystal clear? Want that we should go into its highly chequered and ugly
history? Or perhaps the innumerable times it stopped India, or tried to, from
achieving its justified goals? I respectfully submit that The USA has a far
uglier record than the Israelis who actually are saints by comparison. Remember
the Iraq Fiasco? Where are those WMDs? And yet, we welcome closer ties – because it is the primary world power, and a
much-sought after relationship?
I don’t recall as many questions
being raised on the impact of our relationship with the Russians as we came
closer to The USA. Why is that? So, it is OK if you go after an aspirational
relationship with the premier world power, forgetting our long standing support
from Russia? That is something
that has required far more serious thought, and has been handled very adroitly
by all Central Governments we have had; let us give them credit for that. Thus, cant we cut slack for our Government
and our Diplomatic forces that they can handle Israel and Palestine with equal
aplomb?
Yet, when we come to Israel, we get
instant moralization. Where was this moralization when The USA is involved? Its
human rights record is ugly beyond mention – yet, no controversy. Where was
this moralistic stance when we moved USA-wards, forgetting that it was Russia
who has always stood by us? When has the USA ever stood for us in Geopolitics?
Almost never historically! What’s good for the geese is good for the gander –
you cannot ignore moralistic issues in one relationship, and apply them in
another. You have to apply the precise same standards in each case.
GEOPOLITICS
More serious are the Geopolitical
objections, which to be perfectly frank – deserve a serious reading, and merit
a reasoned response from us. To summarise, these are India-Iran; Arabs; NRIs in
the Middle East; and the Israeli-Chinese relationship. We need to look at all
of these in an informed debate : a dispassionate analysis of these is required,
shorn of ideological baggage. Some of these frankly are fantastic, like the NRI
problem or how our NRIs will be treated due to a relationship with Israel –
that is just stretching things too far. The Arab world also has relations with
Israel!
First, India is seeking alternatives
to OPEC actively, trying to reduce the dependence on it for Oil. Second, some
Arab nations are anyway fedup with Pakistan due to terrorism, and that is a
huge point in our favour. Third, The Arab
World is itself giving overtures to Israel – Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia to
be specific. We are also building relationships with The Arab World, who
can also see our impact in Afghanistan. So, why on earth shouldn’t we build a
relationship with Israel? Fourth, Iran
has seen our support to them in the face of The USA – and our diplomatic forces
can be expected to handle the delicate relationship balance. That leads to
Fifth – the Israel visit comes after a visit to the Arab world!Thus, If we can balance USA and Russia, we can
certainly be expected to balance Iran and Israel, that much seems to be
certain. Let us not sell ourselves short.
Now, the Israeli Chinese
Relationship. Why on earth should this make us uneasy? First of all, Israel is
but of three major defense partners of ours, alongside the USA and Russia. We
have hedged our bets, not being dependent on any one partner. Sure, a lot more
needs to be done, but the direction is right. Second, Israel had supported us
in 1962 against China. While that is no guarantee of the future, it is
nevertheless a significant factor. It actively supported our Armed Forces as well as our anti-terror efforts many
times after that as well, including as recently as in 1999 during the Kargil
conflict. Third – we are perfectly fine
with having a relationship with USA, which is supporting Pakistan openly – but
use a different yardstick to judge the India and Israel relationship! That is
amazing!
PALESTINE
Finally, on Palestine, I accept that
we have been a long-standing supporter of the cause. But we
need to understand that we need to look out for ourselves first. We are in
a world with rapidly re-aligning geopolitical relationships. In such changing
times, we need to change with the times, and respond to the challenges being
raised. A strategic alignment with Israel is a given, as we have many common
points and mutual areas of interest. This is not present in the Palestine
relationship. Furthermore, there is no
other reason to be reticent; we will have
to trust our diplomatic corps to play the balancing role, That is the need of
the hour. There is no such thing as a perfect strategy – it is always give
and take.
CONCLUSION
This does not include the many areas
of trade and scientific commonality that we enjoy with Israel – which is only
just one more added incentive for closer and more open relations with Israel. From
my opinion, my point of view, it sounds slightly hypocritical to talk of our
relations with The USA is one voice, and analyse the Israeli relationship along
diametrically opposite tones. In this, I stand solidly with the Government
praisers – well done, NaMo Government. You have taken a splendid step for the
reasons outined above. That said, it has been a collective effort- it has to be
said that all political parties have stood by this relationship for years and
nurtured it actively.
Selected References :
How time became ripe for Israel visit ; India moving beyond oil as seeks alternatives to OPEC; India's Israel Policy: The Merits of a Pragmatic Approach; 5 reasons why Israel matters to India ; Fact check: From missiles to tomatoes, why Israel is important for Modi; and some others...
Comments
Post a Comment